Eight more months later

Brian Peterson looked at the return on his desk. It was cut and dried, the lady died in a car accident in 2010. He looked at the death certificate and saw Laura Holden’s signature at the bottom, he smiled and looked in the desk drawer at the diamond ring he had bought her when he proposed which was on Friday night. He noticed at that point the third contributing cause of death, suicide. He picked up the telephone and called her. “Hi, honey this is Brian, how’s the smartest most attractive coroner doing?” “Flattery will get you everywhere,” Laura cooed. “This is kind of a business call”, Brian said hesitantly. “What’s up?” Laura replied. “I’m looking at a death certificate for Bea Gooding and your signature is on it, could you pull your file on that case?” Brian asked. “Sure”, Laura answered. She pulled the file and came back to the phone, “Brian, yea, it was a single car accident, no witnesses, drove right into a concrete barrier, died of trauma shortly after the accident, never regain consciousness. I put suicide as a possible contributing cause, because single car accidents are almost always suicides. Why are you interested in my autopsy?” Brian cleared his throat. “Its possible, that her suicide could be grounds to assert tax fraud, we’ve never tried it, but it means about $150 Million of difference taxwise”. “Wow”, Laura replied. “The problem is that its only a hunch on my part”, Laura said. “For all I know she could have dozed off, it was late at night, or she could have been blinded by a car light, or dropped something on the floor and reached down to pick it up. How right do you want me to be on this?” Brian thought for a moment and asked, “Did anyone find a suicide note?” “No, not that I am aware of”, Laura replied. “You need to ask the family that question”.

Nine Months Later

No her daughter was not pregnant. Bea’s attorney filed the Federal Estate Tax return. Her net estate after funeral expenses and debts was $299,985,000. The Estate tax bill was zero since she died in the year 2010. (Nota Bene this is still currently the law which could be changed at any moment). The return was filed with the Internal Revenue Service and marked for prompt assessment. As required by the regulations a copy of the death certificate was appended to the return. (At this point the story could go in two directions – namely if Congress retroactively reimposed an estate tax and the other if Congress did not, we will follow the later assumption). By filing a request for prompt assessment, the Service has nine months to audit the return or the Executor is personally off the hook for the tax.

Re-energized

Its been a tough month. Eight clients passed away in the past six weeks, so things have been hectic, tax season upon us, and of course the usual work load. There is still no Estate Tax bill out of either house of Congress. The President proposed in his 2011 Budget to reenact the Estate Tax with a $3.5 Million Unified Credit Exemption per person ($7 Million per couple) with a 45% rate. The Senate has a bi-partisan proposal at $5 Million per person ($10 Million per couple) with a 35% rate. Stay tuned.

No excuses just facts. Okay back to Grandma tomorrow.

The Note

When Becky entered her mother’s house, she saw a note on the kitchen counter. “Dear children, I know you are grieving and by now are probably wondering what happened. Yes, I killed myself by car accident to save you estate taxes. There are several things you need to not do. 1. Don’t apply for any life insurance benefits. They won’t pay and will order a coroner’s inquest. 2. Destroy this letter. Don’t save it for posterity, it will only cause you grief. 3. Know that I did this because I love you.”

Becky cried. No amount of money was worth her mother’s life. None. She dutifully destroyed the letter by lighting it on fire in the kitchen sink and washing the ashes down the garbage disposal.

Death

At 11:25 p.m., her heart stopped. The doctors tried to revive her, but at 11:35 p.m. she passed away. The doctors informed her children of the results. “We tried, but her injuries were just too great”.

On January 4, 2011, Laura Holden looked at what was left of Beatrice’s body on her autopsy table. Clearly consistent with a car accident. She took some toxicology screens and found no evidence of drugs or alcohol. She looked at the death certificate signed by the doctor and saw as the third cause “Possible Suicide” and the time and date of death. She shook her head, suicides were always the worst from auto accidents because that meant a coroner’s inquest might be requested by an insurance company.